I'm Still Standing

Chief Investment Officer, Model Portfolios

And did you think this fool could never win
Well look at me, I'm coming back again
I got a taste of love in a simple way
And if you need to know while I'm still standing
You just fade away

Don't you know
I'm still standing better than I ever did
Looking like a true survivor, feeling like a little kid
And I'm still standing after all this time
Picking up the pieces of my life
Without you on my mind…
(From “I’m Still Standing,” by Elton John and Bernie Taupin, 1983)

We have asked the question before—whether or not it was time for value investing to come back—and we’ve also discussed different reasons that may explain its rather lengthy underperformance. As we await the final election results (which we may not know until early December), it seems an appropriate time to revisit this question. Is now the time that value comes back?

Let’s begin by reviewing YTD performance of growth versus value:

Figure 1_Value vs growth

For definitions of indexes in the chart, please visit our glossary.

It is also important to remember that the growth index has been utterly dominated by a small handful of mega-cap tech stocks (e.g., Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, Alphabet [Google], Apple and Microsoft).

If we accept that the economy is slowly recovering (with uncertainty, given the “third-wave” spike in the number of new COVID-19 cases), and that the market is expecting an additional massive fiscal stimulus bill (regardless of the election outcome), then it is worth reviewing again how value stocks have historically performed relative to growth stocks during economic recoveries:

Figure 2_Value vs Growth

Historically, value stocks outperformed during periods of economic recovery (e.g., after the 2000 “tech bubble crash” and the 2008–2009 financial crisis), but we see dramatic underperformance in this most recent period of economic recovery. Again, the dominance of the mega-cap tech stocks in driving recent market performance cannot be overstated, and it distorts the seemingly gaping performance dispersion between growth and value stocks.

What about valuations? Compare the valuations of the Russell 1000 Growth Index to those of the Russell 1000 Value Index:

Growth vs value table

By almost any metric you choose, value stocks look dramatically more attractive than growth stocks from a fundamental valuation perspective. Remember, what you earn on an investment over the longer term is very much dependent on how much you pay for it today. Unless “this time it’s different” (which it almost never is), then normal market cyclicality suggests that value is due for a comeback.

Finally, let’s revisit the economic regimes when value (historically) has done best:

Figure 3_business cycle

For definitions of terms in the chart, please visit our glossary.

The details of any fiscal stimulus package will be very dependent on the election outcome. But regardless of the outcome, we do expect another round of massive fiscal stimulus, which should give a boost to the  economic recovery, at least in the short term. We believe that the stimulus may reset the economic recovery stage back down  to where we point to in the chart—historically, a good time for value.

Value may be set up for what we believe is a long-overdue comeback, and many of the WisdomTree product strategies and model portfolios are, in our opinion, well-positioned to capitalize on that value recovery.

Value investing may, once again, prove to be “still standing.”

Important Risks Related to this Article

References to specific securities and their issuers are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to be, and should not be interpreted as, recommendations to purchase or sell such securities.

For more investing insights, check out our Economic & Market Outlook


About the Contributor
Chief Investment Officer, Model Portfolios
Scott Welch is the Chief Investment Officer of Model Portfolios at WisdomTree, a provider of factor-based ETFs, differentiated model portfolios, and digital asset solutions. In his role as CIO, he oversees the construction and ongoing management of the WisdomTree model portfolio solution set. He chairs the WisdomTree Model Portfolio Investment Committee and is an active member of the WisdomTree Asset Allocation team. Prior to joining WisdomTree, Scott was the Chief Investment Officer of Dynasty Financial Partners, a provider of outsourced investment research, portfolio management, technology, and practice management solutions to RIAs and advisory teams making the move to independence. Prior to Dynasty, Scott was a Co-Founder and the Chief Investment Officer of Fortigent, LLC, a provider of outsourced investment research, technology, and practice management solutions to RIAs and banks that targeted high net worth investors. Scott holds the Certified Investment Management Analyst (CIMA®) designation, and he sits on the Board of Directors of the Investments & Wealth Institute (IWI, formerly known as IMCA) and is an outside member of several RIA Investment Committees. Scott earned a Bachelor of Science in Mathematics from the University of California at Irvine and an MBA with a concentration in Finance from the University of Massachusetts at Amherst.