Emerging Markets and State Owned Enterprises

When investors allocate to emerging markets, they typically do so through broad-based market cap-weighted exposure. More recently, investors have shown interest in specific cuts or subsets of the broader emerging markets, such as country rotation, high-dividend-yield strategies, small caps, low volatility and other investment strategies. We’ve seen growing interest in the degree of exposure to state-owned enterprises (SOE) in various investment strategies. State-owned enterprises are typically defined as companies that are either wholly or partially owned or operated by a government. Some investors believe that government ownership can negatively impact the operational aspects of a company because government-owned companies might be influenced by a broader set of interests, beyond generating profits for shareholders. Characteristics of State-Owned Enterprises State ownership levels can vary significantly among sectors and countries, depending both on a sector’s significance for providing public goods or fostering economic growth and on the governmental structure. WisdomTree identified 424 companies out of an initial 3,000 companies in emerging markets as state-owned enterprises (SOE), with government owning more than 20% of shares. The SOEs had market cap of over $1.31 trillion, about 26% of the original universe’s market cap of approximately $5.07 trillion.¹ Figures 1 and 2 illustrate the market cap profiles of the SOE universe by sectors and countries.   Figure 1: State-Owned Enterprises by Sector • Ownership Concentrated among Public Good Sectors: Given that the Financials, Energy, Telecom and Utilities sectors are among the most systemically important sectors to economic development, we are not surprised that governments tend to play a more active role in these sectors.   • Less Ownership among Private Good Sectors: Currently, governments are less involved in the Consumer Discretionary and Consumer Staples, Information Technology and Health Care sectors. Companies in many consumer-focused sectors tend to be less vital to the strategic economic development and welfare of emerging market governments. These sectors also are often the focus for growth investors who see a burgeoning opportunity as emerging market consumers develop and increase their income and standard of living.   Figure 2: State-Owned Enterprises by Country • China Displayed the Largest Government Involvement: Given China’s communist background, it is not surprising that almost half of the SOE market cap companies are Chinese companies. A large percentage of the Chinese government’s market cap ownership comes from the stakes it holds in the country’s large financial institutions. These large state-owned banks are among the lowest-priced areas of the entire emerging markets, with average dividend yields over 6% and price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios below 5x.²   • Russia Also Displayed Significant Government Involvement: Russia’s socialist and communist history has led to noteworthy government ownership in the Energy and Financials sectors. Although the recent Ukrainian conflicts have further depressed valuations, the Russian Energy sector had already displayed depressed valuations compared to the broader emerging markets before the crisis. For example, Gazprom and Rosneft, two of the largest state-owned energy companies, have dividend yields north of 5% and P/E ratios under 5x.³   WisdomTree Emerging Markets ex-State-Owned Enterprises Index WisdomTree created a broad-based Index to emerging market stocks that are not state-owned enterprises; this Index will help investors monitor the performance of this subset. In a future blog post, we will introduce this new Index, the WisdomTree Emerging Markets ex-State-Owned Enterprises (EMXSOE), designed to measure the performance of broad-based emerging market stocks that exclude state-owned companies.         ¹Sources: WisdomTree, Standard and Poor’s, as of 7/31/14. ²Sources: WisdomTree, Bloomberg; refers to the five largest dividend-paying Chinese banks as of 9/30/14. ³Sources: WisdomTree, Bloomberg, as of 9/30/14. The WisdomTree Emerging Markets Ex State Owned Enterprises Index does not hold Gazprom or Rosneft.