Longer-term interest rates in the U.S. have risen considerably since May on speculation the Federal Reserve may begin tapering
its quantitative easing (QE)
program. Even though, as of September 2013, tapering has yet to begin, in our most recent Market Insight
, I evaluated how the recent rise in interest rates has impacted various income-oriented investment strategies. Among other things, I discussed the general effects that the recent interest rate hikes had on the different sectors of the S&P 500 Index
Ned Davis Research recently published a similar analysis on the 10 S&P 500 Index sectors and their sensitivity to the 10-year Treasury yield
over the past 36 months, displayed as 10-year yield beta
, below. Higher 10-year yield beta numbers signal a positive performance relationship (compared to the S&P 500 Index) when 10-Year Treasury yields were rising; negative numbers imply a negative performance relationship. In other words, a positive 10-year yield beta showed a sector outperforming, while a negative 10-year yield beta showed a sector underperforming the S&P 500.
• Defensive Sectors Show Negative Relationship to Rising Yields
– All of the defensive sectors displayed a negative relationship to rising yields, as shown through the 10-year yield beta metric. The Utilities and Telecommunication Services sectors showed the highest negative sensitivity over the period. Now, past performance does not guarantee future results, but if this relationship holds, you might expect these sectors to underperform the S&P 500 Index during a rising rate environment.
• Cyclical Sectors Show Positive Sensitivity to Rising Yields
– Most of the cyclical sectors displayed a positive relationship to rising yields, as shown through the 10-year yield beta metric. The Financials and Energy sectors showed the highest positive sensitivity over the period. If this relationship were to hold, you might expect these sectors to outperform the S&P 500 Index during a rising rate environment.
S&P 500 Sector Performance
In the same market insight
, I looked at the performance of the S&P 500 sectors over the most recent period of rising Treasury yields, from April 30 to August 20, 2013. This period was chosen because it exhibited a steady rise in the 10-Year Treasury yield, from 1.63% to 2.81%. Although the above research from Ned Davis looked at the relative sector performance over the past 36 months, we found similar results.
• The three sectors with the highest negative yield beta (Consumer Staples, Utilities and Telecommunications) were the three worst-performing sectors over the period. These sectors also exhibited the highest dividend yields
over the period.
• Sectors with higher earnings growth expectations (and lower dividend yields) were in the upper part of the performance spectrum. Typically, these sectors fall into the cyclically sensitive category and perform well when the economy is expanding.
Conclusion and WisdomTree Solutions
The recent spike in Treasury yields has caused a reevaluation of many equity strategies and an underperformance for the sectors with the highest dividend yields—typically Utilities and Telecommunication sectors. Investors should potentially look to the higher-growing and lower-yielding sectors in order to lower their portfolios’ sensitivity to potential further increases in Treasury yields.
WisdomTree has launched a family of dividend growth-oriented ETFs
that include a Fund each for U.S. large caps and U.S. small caps, and we believe they are particularly well suited for a rising interest rate environment, as they tend to be more cyclically exposed and less exposed to Telecommunication and Utilities (which typically are higher-yield sectors and less dividend growth oriented).
For more information on these new ETFs, please see:
1) Large Caps: WisdomTree U.S. Dividend Growth ETF (DGRW)
2) Small Caps: WisdomTree U.S. SmallCap Dividend Growth ETF (DGRS)